By A Web Design

Merkel's Leading Germany Into an Abyss



.Euro02

Despite weakening economic growth and industrial production in recent months, Germany continues to look much better than the rest of Europe on the surface. It boasts a very low unemployment rate (although uber low-wage work has grown tremondously) and relatively small public deficits. However, none of that is stopping Merkel and her administration from betting their re-election on the fact that they can implement significant austerity in the next 2 years, while also containing the Euro crisis, and "lead by example". Sven Böll, Peter Müller and Christian Reiermann report for Der Spiegel:

   

Leading by Example: Merkel Bets Austerity Will Result in Re-Election

 

Just how healthy German finances are was revealed at the beginning of last week, in the form of an early-warning report by the European Commission. Germany was the only large country to be given an almost perfect grade.

 

And yet, if Merkel and Schäuble have their way, the country many in Europe already see as a model of sound budget management will become even more exemplary. "We cannot expect Greece and the other crisis-stricken countries to accept more and more austerity measures, while nothing changes in Germany," says a close associate of the chancellor.

 

As such, Merkel and Schäuble want to significantly ratchet up consolidation efforts. The 2013 budget, currently being prepared at the Finance Ministry, will include many billions in savings. In addition, the last stage of the so-called debt brake -- Germany's constitutionally anchored law regulating state borrowing -- will be brought forward by two years instead of going into effect as planned in 2016. Measures under discussion include cuts in social benefits and a reduction in government services. Merkel and Schäuble believe that Germany can only remain credible in the euro crisis by demonstrating that it is not simply reaping the benefits of past efforts. Germany wants to lead by example.

In other words, the German populace is about to find out just how destructive austerity can be to an economy when the world is in the midst of an ongoing Depression, in a system that values credit creation above all else. Of course, the most immediate threat to the Germany economy is financial contagion when (again, not if) Greece exits the Eurozone, which will certainly be within 0-2 years. Merkel is also betting that this will now be contained, primarily due to the ECB's LTRO programs (the second one to occur in a week). If you ask me, that's a lot of losing bets she's placing on the table. Back to the austerity:

It's an ambitious goal. To achieve it, the coalition will have to adhere to strict austerity rules in the current year's budget, but especially when assembling the budget for 2013. According to CDU deputy floor leader Michael Meister, new borrowing will remain at €26.1 billion this year, even though the first installments of at least €8.6 billion for the new euro bailout fund, the European Stability Mechanism (ESM), will come due in the summer. Meister intends to achieve this goal primarily through "smart budget management." In other words, each of the 5,500 items in the budget will be closely examined and will be granted only as much as absolutely necessary.

 

In addition, tax revenues last autumn were significantly higher than forecast. And Germany has also saved billions on sovereign bond interest rates, with returns at record lows due to the ongoing euro crisis.

 

The challenges will be greater next year. In 2013, the finance minister hopes to reduce new borrowing to €15 billion. But because the planned financial transaction tax cannot be implemented throughout Europe, and a number of additional expenses will be incurred, Schäuble will have to find some €10 billion in order to hit his target.

 

That is the primary motivation for assembling a new austerity package. Finance Ministry officials already have a clear idea of what it should look like. In particular, they have set their sights on the social benefits coffers, which, thanks to a strong economy, are currently well funded. Federal healthcare subsidies are to be reduced by up to €2 billion and the government's contribution to the pension insurance system is to be trimmed by a similar amount. Both cuts are to be lasting.

 

Schäuble also intends to cut the budget of the Federal Employment Agency by several hundred million euros and to cap outlays for the parental leave allowance program, expenditures for which have risen substantially in recent years.

As explained in Employment = Poverty and Inequality, the German populace is not in a great position to absorb these cuts to social spending that amount to almost a 40% reduction in new borrowing by next year, and 100% in the next two. Many of them are performing part-time, low-wage work that has greatly exacerbated wealth inequality within the population. As the German export industry is squeezed from the revenue side of the equation due to extremely low demand in Europe and the world, it will be forced to lay off workers and cut wages further, placing even more people into relative poverty.

 

POPULATION BELOW POVERTY LINE (%)

indexmundi ex69

 

Assuming that everything is contained within the Euro crisis, and Greece either stays in without further German money or exits peacefully (fat chance!), these "exemplary" and ambitious austerity plans will simply place more downward pressure on German aggregate domestic demand, economic growth and tax revenues, making its deficit situation worse over time. That is especially true if Merkel sticks with the Euro experiment and is forced to pony up ever-growing sums of bailout money and Germany's sovereign borrowing costs correspondingly rise. So Merkel may be leading Germany and Europe by example, but she's leading them straight into the depths of economic depression and sociopolitical chaos.

Posted: 2 months, 3 weeks ago by MR166 #501
So governments are dammed if they do and dammed if they don't.

Run a deficit------dammed
Reduce a deficit----dammed
Raise taxes to reduce deficit-----dammed
Lower taxes and deficit------ good trick if you can do it
Posted: 2 months, 3 weeks ago by Greenpa #502
The Christian Science Monitor says it, right out loud:

www.csmonitor.com/World/Europe/2012/0222/Greece-begrudgingly-cedes-sovereignty-in-exchange-for-bailout-funds

Reasonably good analysis there. To me- Greece is a country ripe to bursting for a charismatic leader to arise, and take control. Then? Pure crapshoot. Time frame for a new charismatic to reach control, in my mind- a year, or thereabouts.
Posted: 2 months, 3 weeks ago by ashvin #503
Posted: 2 months, 3 weeks ago by Greenpa #504
MR166 - yep, dams all over. The problem, if I can revert to veterinary metaphor; is that all the "economists" of the world are struggling to help the Cow Of International Commerce give birth. It's a hard birth; breech, in fact, and a small birth canal. So, gosh, it's difficult. And they're positive it's twins in there, too.

Thing is- they don't have a cow- what they actually have is a bull- which isn't going to give birth, no matter what- and the bull has two broken legs. But the "expert financial technicians" only see a cow in labor; so- no; nothing they're recommending is going to get the animal back on its feet.

That is, in fact, a basic precept in the pursuit of Understanding. If the answers you keep getting don't work- there's a huge chance you have not asked the correct question. That's pretty much where western civilization is right now. Eager to solve all our problems- but in fact we don't see what the true problems are.
Posted: 2 months, 3 weeks ago by Greenpa #505
woohoo! We can paste graphics? Ok, that's fun...
Posted: 2 months, 3 weeks ago by MayAllBWell #507
Ash, would you please give me some clarity. I'm long familiar, and to a very large part, long agreeing with TAE. Recently i've been reading ZeroHedge a lot. Tyler states over and over his findings that central banks globally have been printing, printing, printing, flooding the world with money in a race, and that there is $2 trillion more now in circulation than in the summer. Is this true?
Posted: 2 months, 3 weeks ago by MR166 #508
And we might as well add to that, if they plan to pay off all of this debt with phoney money when will inflation rear it's ugly head. If the answer is never since destruction of debt is depressive then why is this not a good long term plan for all governments.
Posted: 2 months, 3 weeks ago by Phil #509
Am I alone in wishing that the byline be at the top of the post rather than at the bottom of it? These things matter! Doom, gloom, etc
Posted: 2 months, 3 weeks ago by ashvin #510
What loose monetary policy such as ZIRP and QE (monetization of debt) do above all else is transfer wealth from savers/workers/taxpayers to corporate elites (and shareholders in the short to medium-term), while also building up the level of imbalances in the markets and general economy. It generally does that by sucking more people (or amounts of productive wealth) into paper asset, consumption/investment bubbles while also undermining general confidence (the trust horizon), creating unintended consequences and sticking taxpayers with the losses on many of the bad assets.

Thus, Ilargi's theme of Wile E Coyote in suspended animation. Sites like ZeroHedge believe that private and public debt deflation will always be met with massive amounts of "money printing", which replaces private credit money that is disappearing with fresh base money from the central banks. They also believe that this will lead to HI of the major currencies, much sooner rather than later. The $2T it refers to is basically the amount that the ECB's balance sheet has expanded since the summer from secondary market purchases of peripheral debt and the LTRO operation (1% 3-year loans backed by very distressed collateral).

OTOH, many of us here believe the situation is more complex than that. First of all, there are many economic, social and political factors that will both limit the amount of money printing and reduce its effectiveness. ZH itself ran an article yesterday about how QE is becoming less and less effective at even propping up the casino paper markets (stocks). In Who Killed the Money Printer and Political Theater Will Kill the Status Quo, I pointed out how near-term political factors can disrupt the drive to monetize debts as well.

ZH also had an article yesterday about how the some ECB officials (and the Bundesbank) is worried about the imbalances/unintended consequences of LTRO and may end the operation after the second one next week. Which also brings us to the next point that monetization of debts does not necessarily translate into inflation/HI because very little of the money makes it outside of the banking system, and LTRO may even slow down the velocity of money in the Euro periphery (Unintended Consequences of LTRO].

We must also distinguish between the likelihood of inflation/HI in peripheral parts of the global economy from central parts. The former include the Euro periphery (and most imminently Greece), parts of Asia, the ME and perhaps South America. As Stoneleigh has pointed out, collapse (including monetary collapse] typically starts in the periphery and then progresses to the center. We are still in the early stages of that collapse, since no significant economy has experienced very high inflation or HI yet.

HI will eventually show up in the developed world down the road, and at a time when people are least expecting it and can least afford it (even less than now). However, it's not as simple as every major currency blowing up at the same time in the next few years. The process will be drawn out and debt deflation will make that time seem like an eternity for many people with low incomes, debts, low savings, lack of preparation, etc. That has been a pillar of I&S' message here from the beginning - getting through the short and medium-term so you have a long-term to worry about.
Posted: 2 months, 3 weeks ago by MayAllBWell #512
Thanks Ash, for your generous willingness to address questions. Tyler repeatedly says (this is a quote from a post today) that "due to $2 trillion in liquidity *** dumped into markets *** by central banks". That seems to imply the liquidity ends up in the market - you say it stays at the banks - would you be willing to clarify?

Also, i've been thinking of a post i would someday post on ZeroHedge to balance out the HI leanings: That, even though many creditors will go belly up when things collapse, there will be some creditors standing. They are, essentially, loan sharks. They will want to be paid on the debts owed them. There is not enough gold on Earth to act as currency, so they must choose one currency to act as the standard and will want that currency to maintain value.

The surviving debtors (especially sovereigns) on the other hand will want to dilute all currencies in order to not pay/pay less to the loan sharks.

So the question is who has more influence/control in a such a situation. TAE feels that the loan sharks will have more power (at least initially) and HI'ists feel the sovereigns will have more power/choice to outprint the loan sharks.

What do you think of this explanation/simplification?
Posted: 2 months, 3 weeks ago by Stevo #517
Hi Ash,
I wonder if an effect of the seemingly large QE and LTRO of the US and Europe is to dilute and thereby proportionately reduce in value the current store of money/assets held by banks? If these additioons to the shrinking money supply do not go outside the banks then they have no inflationary effect.on the cost of general goods and services. But the impact is still inflationary on money wealth. The owners of the existing stock of money are thereby effectively paying the costs of propping up the private banking system, so it can still fund the roll-over of sovereign debt??
Posted: 2 months, 3 weeks ago by NZSanctuary #518
The rhetoric against Iran is flowing thick and fast now. Either support is won for a "pre-emptive" strike, or something BIG is on the horizon that will be blamed on Iran to cement the deal.

www.nzherald.co.nz/world/news/article.cfm?c_id=2&objectid=10787333
Posted: 2 months, 3 weeks ago by entropy #524
Posted: 2 months, 3 weeks ago by el gallinazo #525
The question about a war with Iran centers around the question of whether the US military could reopen the Straits of Hormuz in a short period of time. If they believe they can, then they will go to war. Believing they can and doing it are two different sacks of fish. I suspect that the Iranian military are far more capable than many predict. And then there is Russia and China. Can they afford an Western takeover of Iran, and if not, what are they going to do about it? And then there is also the factor of the Zionist tail wagging the US dog. If the Straits are closed for six months or more, which I see to be quite likely, then the global Ponzi will certainly collapse. One school of conspiracy factists believe that the NWO strategists wishes to collapse the Ponzi in order to rebuild with a world currency and government.

Recommend Dmitri Orlov's interview with Max Keiser at:



Also, Club Orlov has some outstanding recent articles and letters as well as a link to an excellent animation.

Orlov had to amend is five stages of collapse recently from watching the financial quackery taking place. He original saw them in succession, financial, economic, then political, but now he sees them as a simultaneous pile-up. This is what the NWO attempt to save the banking Ponzi since the first collapse has brought. He also puts forth the idea, which I&S also support, that the American Empire will collapse when the rest of the world will no longer trade its real goods for paper with pictures of dead white men and electrons. He claims that in the end, this is what collapsed the Soviet Union. Orlov states that in its last days, Gorbachev approached Washington through Helmut Kohl to bail them out, and Orlov never seems to get his facts wrong.

When asked about the coming FaceBook and Zuckerberg IPO, Orlov's comment is that you know that the economy is near collapse when its touted pinnacle is a time wasting diversion. By the way, unlike the Hotel California, it is possible to quit FaceBook, though the path out is laborious. My advice is just mail your upcoming itinerary direct to Vaterland Insecurity. You¡ll be saving them and yourself a lot of time.

CHS today also put forth a rigorous piece of analogous reasoning which would indicate that the Ponzi will collapse suddenly in the end. This supports I&S idea of a period of monetary deflation, because the central banks will be unable to "print" on a scale to counteract this sort of collapse. The HI financial counterculture (ZH for example) is using the idea of "printing" very loosely. In Weimar and Zimbabwe, the paper money was printed and distributed, after a large government cut, to the pissants. This resulted in a straight forward dilution of the value of the currency. What TPTB are now doing is just trading credit of the central banks to the TBTF banks, who then put the money into sovereign debt or market speculation in a giant, transgovernmental circle jerk. That is why we have not seen HI inflation yet. Most of the credit never reaches the common man. It does raise the world market price of stuff by commodity speculation, but since the vast majority of people around the globe are seeing their income decrease, this just means that they can buy less essential stuff, and limits a "price inflationary" spiral. And by the Austrian school definition, the globe is seeing net deflation, manifested at this stage by the collapse of the shadow banking system and many hedge funds.
Posted: 2 months, 3 weeks ago by Trichter #527
Can definitely confirm the point Ash makes in the article. Despite Germany's much-touted status as "Exportweltmeister" (export world champion). Life on the ground is getting harder and harder for the people. It was perfectly summed up by laconis t-shirt a family father I saw walking down the street in Berlin with his daughter. It read:

"Arm trotz Arbeit" (Poor Despite Having Job)

They are squeezing people hard. A serious backlash will come from right and left factions.
Posted: 2 months, 3 weeks ago by jal #528
@ eg
The circle jerk, as you have stated, does affect the outcome definition of deflation/inflation.

It may end up in a sudden collapse but so far everything is on slow boil.
Posted: 2 months, 3 weeks ago by el gallinazo #530
"The slow boil" reminds me of the Yellowstone NP fire disaster. The "moral hazard" of the TBTF and their political puppets is leading to a total conflagration in all the markets.
Posted: 2 months, 3 weeks ago by MR166 #531
Hummmn, petroleum usage in the US is plummeting but oil prices are up big time despite a steady to increasing dollar. HI might be closer than we think. Yes, Iran is a big unknown but is it production worries or devaluation that is causing this spike.
Posted: 2 months, 3 weeks ago by Patrick #582
greenpa,

I think the good ole US of A is the most likely candidate for a charismatic leader to take over. Won't say it *can't* happen in Greece but their experience with dictatorship is fresh and painful. Amurica otoh, has this, as James Kunstler would call it, tendency to "corn-pone fascism." Can picture some general like Petreaus standing up and claiming the US was "stabbed in the back" by traitorous leaders.

Discuss this article
You need to log in or register to participate in this discussion.







 

Blog Archive

Powered by mod LCA


Stoneleigh Occupies:

 

Australia and New Zealand

Check the Facebook TAE Tour Page

Feb 9 Sunshine Coast
The Big Pineapple, Woombye 6pm

Feb 10 The Channon
Channon Community Hall 6pm

Feb 11 Coff’s Harbour
Cavanbah Hall 12pm

Feb 12 Bungendore NSW
Mulloon Creek Natural Farms 3.30-9pm

Feb 13 Canberra
CSIRO Discovery Centre 7.30pm

Feb 16 Daylesford
Daylesford Town Hall 7pm

Feb 17 Melbourne
Federation Square Sustainable Living Festival evening

Feb 18 Melbourne
Federation Square Sustainable Living Festival 3pm

Feb 19 Brunswick
Ceres Community Environment Park 9am-3.30pm (with Steve Keen)

Feb 21 Leongatha
Memorial Hall 6.30pm

Feb 22 Geelong
Gordon TAFE Auditorium 6pm

Feb 23 Adelaide
Hawke Centre, University of South Australia, West Campus 4pm

Feb 24 Fremantle
Fremantle Town Hall 7pm

Feb 28 Margaret River
Margaret River District Club 7pm

Feb 29 Albany
George's Restaurant, Great Southern Institute of Technology 6.30pm

Mar 1 Manjimup
Library Gallery Room 6pm

Mar 8 Perth
Perth Town Hall 5pm

Mar 9 Guildford
St Matthew's Hall 6pm

Mar 11 Fremantle
Fremantle Town Hall, All Day Ecoburbia Conference 10am-4pm

Mar 13 Hobart
Centenary Lecture Theatre 7pm

Mar 15 Launceston
Lecture Theatre 9, Faculty of Arts 7pm

 

New Zealand

Mar 19 Waititi
Waititi Community Hall 7pm

Mar 20 Otago
Archway 4 Lecture Theater UofO 5.15pm

Mar 21 Hampden
Hampden Hall 7pm

Mar 23 Christchurch
CPIT 12pm

Mar 23 Christchurch
CPIT 6pm

Mar 27 Lyttleton
Naval Point Club 5pm

Mar 29 Richmond
Tasman District Library 12.30pm

Mar 29 Motueka
Community House Docks Reserve 7.30pm

Mar 30 Nelson
Victory Community Center 5.30pm

Apr 2 Takaka
Senior Citizens Hall 7pm

Apr 5 Wellington Turnbull House 12pm

Apr 7 Otaki Clean Technology Centre 1.30pm

Apr 10 Wanganui
Venue TBC 7pm

Apr 11-15 Turangi
11th Australasian Permaculture Convergence

Apr 16 Hamilton
Hamilton City Council reception lounge 12pm

Apr 16 Auckland
RSC, 1 Francis St., Grey Lynn 7pm

Apr 17 Waiheke Island
Waiheke Community Cinema, 2 Korora Rd. 7pm

Apr 19 Auckland
University of Auckland, Case Room 1, Owen Glenn Building.6pm

Apr 20 Auckland
SBN breakfast, Level 3, Old Sofrana House 8am

Apr 20 Auckland
Direction Healing Centre, 12 Horopito St., Mt Eden 7pm

 

Australia

Apr 22 Brisbane
Jagara Arts Centre 6pm

Apr 24 Sunshine Coast
The Big Pineapple, Woombye 6pm

May 11 Cairns
JCU Campus4pm

May 12 Malanda
CWA Hall 6pm

May 13 Cairns
Redlynch State College, Redlynch, Cairns 6pm

 


Europe May-Aug 2012 Dates available

Request Lectures: StoneleighTravels •at• gmail •dot• com.


Follow Us:


 
Get free email alerts for The Automatic Earth
Email:

You can support TAE by ordering all your Amazon purchases through this search box:




Google Translation